Sign Up for Harry Potter's Page Newsletter

Login :: Register

Here's the news on everything Harry Potter!

It's a Fan Showdown: Harry Potter vs Twlight

The Examiner in Miami is looking for both Harry Potter and Twilight fans for a showdown. They need three debaters to represent each side of the fandom: three on Team Potter and three on Team Twilight. To qualify, you must have read all seven books for Potter and all four books for Twilight (the movies don't count) and you must absolutely loathe one or the other. If you're interested in being part of the debate, go here! Enjoy!

9 Dec 08| by Dijares | Category SS Book, COS Book, POA Book, GOF Book, OOTP Book, HBP Book, DH Book, Twilight | Views 1540 | Comments 7 | Submit News Print | RSS | Return Home |

by @ 10 Dec 2008 - 01:05

i wish they'd make a poll, and the whole world would have to take it. That would be interesting. :P I like both of them, but Harry Potter has more to it and is better written. Twilight is just a teens thing

by jujubee @ 10 Dec 2008 - 00:32

Hmmmm. The creator of the debate flat out says that because fans of both books are already snarking and fighting with each other, she basically wants to egg it on and get them into a 'good old-fashioned knock down'. This is why it gets so annoying. It's pointless.

by taylor @ 9 Dec 2008 - 21:54

the main reason i dont like twilight is because it was compared to harry potter, which isnt possible. also, twilight was horribly written, so there

by Dijares @ 9 Dec 2008 - 18:10

Jeez, guys, slow down - it's just a debate for those who want to stick up for which one they want to...It's all in good fun.

by bets @ 9 Dec 2008 - 16:49

remind me why i would waist my time loathing either of them? seriously, they both rok so get over it

by seeker15 @ 9 Dec 2008 - 16:38

OMG!!!!! STOP PITTING THEM AGAINST EACH OTHER!!!!!!!!!!!! THIS IS SOOOOOOO STUPID!!!!!!! MANY, MANY, MANY OF THE HARRY POTTER FANS I KNOW ARE ALSO FANS OF THE TWILIGHT SERIES, ME BEING ONE OF THEM!!!!!!!!!!! IT DOESN'T HAVE TO BE A COMPETITION!!!!! THEY ARE BOTH PHENOMENAL BOOKS!!!!!!!!! THIS IS SO ANNOYING!!!!!!!!!!!!

by jujubee @ 9 Dec 2008 - 15:06

Oh my word! Seriously. This is getting so old, and is so annoying. Why WHY must this keep going on. All because someone said that SM could be bigger than JKR, and Rob happens to be the main in Twilight? Why not Twilight vs. Narnia? or Twilight vs. LOTR? Both of which happen to be better than HP and Twilight, IMO. So why not try to take them down? It's beyond annoying and ridiculous now. Some like HP and not Twilight, and some like Twilight and not HP. Why can't it just be left at that? *rolls eyes*

Name:
Mail:	(optional)
Smile:
Enter these letters in the field below.